Take all the iconic ingredients of Star Wars - samurai-inspired sword fights in space, adventurous escapades with Wookiees, aliens speaking in puzzling backwards syntax, and evil cyborgs who kill with telekinesis - then imagine if George Lucas hadn’t wrapped it all up in a family-friendly PG coating.
That’s exactly what Ryan Reynolds pitched to Disney when he suggested an R-rated Star Wars. “I said, ‘Why don’t we do an R-rated Star Wars property?’” Reynolds revealed on The Box Office podcast.
“It doesn’t have to be overtly vulgar or full of A+ characters. There’s a wide range of characters you could use. R-rated as a Trojan horse for emotion.” Translation? Expect more grit, more edge, and yes, more swearing and adult themes.
This pitch has divided critics and fans alike. The Guardian noted that “Star Wars owes much of its original spirit to the samurai films of Akira Kurosawa, which were far from family-friendly.”
They suggested that “an R-rated Star Wars could reconnect the franchise with its raw, violent roots, perhaps even revitalising it after years of safe, sanitized offerings.”
However, he cautioned that “there is a risk that too much grit and swearing could alienate the core family audience and undermine the mythic qualities that have long defined the series.”
Similarly, The Hollywood Reporter, described Reynolds’s concept as “an intriguing proposition in a cinematic landscape saturated with superhero franchises leaning into darker, more adult themes.”
They argued that “shows like Andor have already begun peeling back the fairytale sheen from Star Wars, proving there’s appetite for stories with more moral complexity and emotional weight.”
Yet concern was also raised about tonal balance: “Star Wars has always walked a tightrope between fantasy and grit - tipping too far in either direction could be jarring for long-term fans.”
Imagining this adult take, industry insiders have speculated what it might look like. One anonymous source familiar with Disney’s strategy told Variety that “a Tarantino-style Star Wars, with explicit violence and mature themes, would be a bold move - something to distinguish the franchise in a crowded streaming and cinema market.”
The insider added, “Ryan Reynolds’s brand of snark and irreverence could bring fresh energy, but there’s a fine line between innovation and disrespecting the franchise’s legacy.”
The idea isn’t without precedent. Star Wars has never been shy about darkness and violence.
From the infamous patricide scene where Darth Vader severs Luke’s hand to Jabba the Hutt’s grotesque captivity of Princess Leia, the saga has always contained moments far from family-friendly.
Read More
Series like Andor and Rogue One have demonstrated that audiences are open to grittier narratives, focusing on espionage, political intrigue, and moral ambiguity.
Still, some fans and commentators warn that injecting too much swearing and “Deadpool-style” irreverence risks turning Star Wars into a parody of itself. As critic Alison Willmore of Vulture put it, “the franchise’s strength lies in its earnestness and mythic storytelling - a self-aware, snarky tone might unravel the emotional core and leave fans cold.”
Whether Reynolds’s vision will move beyond the realm of pitch remains to be seen, but the conversation it has sparked reveals an evolving appetite for more mature content within the galaxy far, far away.
As The Atlantic recently observed, “Star Wars sits at a crossroads - it can continue playing it safe or lean into the messy, complicated humanity at the heart of its characters. Reynolds’s proposal taps into that tension, for better or worse.”
For now, the galaxy remains mostly PG, but Ryan Reynolds’s push for a darker, swearing, sexier Star Wars has opened the door to possibilities that fans and critics are watching with equal parts excitement and caution.